top of page

When Simply Living is seen as Suspicious

My questions for mall management

State Rep. Janelle Bynum

Editor’s note: The following statement by State Rep. Janelle Bynum, a black lawmaker from Happy Valley, was issued in response to Clackamas Town Center management stating its policy to ask people suspected of loitering to leave in line with priorities to keep people safe, after a recent case involving her daughter and her daughters friends.

On Friday, Sept. 20, 2019, my daughter and her friends were approached by Clackamas Town Center Security and accused of loitering. Clackamas Town Center management should answer these questions:

The incident took place in the parking lot across from the movie theater, which was open to the public and is a common place for people to wait for movies to begin or manage pickups and drop-offs.

At the time, the three teenage girls, two black, one Asian, were simply figuring out how to repair their foiled movie plans after being refused at the Cinemark Theaters because one of the girls lacked an ID.

The girls were in my daughter’s car drinking chocolate milk, eating Kit Kats, and on their phones looking up homecoming dresses. Why were they approached by security? Why was the officer interested in their car? Was his intent to allow them to stay, or was it to ask them to leave? How did he communicate his intent?

The security guard told my daughter that the mall had a “strict no loitering policy.” Please explain in detail in what manner the girls were violating this strict “no loitering policy.” Please explain how this policy is managed throughout the mall property. Please explain the training mall security is given to enforce the policy. Please explain why the woman in the large, white, SUV who was also waiting in the parking lot just a few cars down was not spoken to about the policy. Are the rules different outside of the mall versus inside the mall?

Please explain why older white women have reported being able to sit in their cars for hours in the parking lot and have never been approached about the “strict no-loitering policy. The girls left after the security interaction. What would have been the procedure if the girls had not moved? The vehicle plates were logged and the security person had both a white and a yellow sheet with him. What information was taken and how will it be used in the future?

This story has spawned public outrage because it is yet another example of how African American teens can be doing something as simple as eating candy and drinking chocolate milk and it still qualifies as suspicious activity.

All teens view going to the mall as an American rite of passage and it shouldn’t be exclusive to those who have the right “look.”

State Rep. Janelle Bynum represents parts of Multnomah County and Clackamas County, including the southeastern most part of Portland, most of Happy Valley and Damascus.

1 view


bottom of page